How to Determine Pain and Suffering Compensation After a Car Accident

How to Determine Pain and Suffering Compensation After a Car Accident

In 2024 alone, Florida has witnessed more than 380,000 crashes, leading to over 245,854 injuries according to the FLHSMV report. If you’ve ever been in an accident, you know it’s not just about the physical injuries or the damage to your car. The real impact often lingers long after the crash, affecting your daily life, emotional well-being, and overall quality of life. Pain and suffering aren’t just legal terms; they’re real challenges that many accident victims face. Understanding how these damages are evaluated and what your legal options are can help you secure the compensation you deserve. In this article, we will help you navigate how pain and suffering are evaluated and what legal options are available in Florida.

What Is Pain and Suffering in a Florida Personal Injury Case?

When you’ve been injured in an accident, the impact goes beyond medical bills and lost wages. Physical pain, emotional distress, and a diminished quality of life are just as real as financial losses. In legal terms, these are known as pain and suffering—a form of non-economic damages that Florida law recognizes as compensable under certain conditions.

Pain and suffering can be broken into two primary categories:

Physical pain and suffering – The discomfort, chronic pain, or ongoing medical issues resulting from the injury.
Mental pain and suffering – Emotional distress, PTSD, depression, anxiety, or the psychological toll of dealing with injuries and lifestyle changes.

While medical bills have clear price tags, pain and suffering are subjective and more difficult to quantify. However, Florida law provides methods for determining compensation.

Can You Claim Pain and Suffering in Florida?

Florida follows a no-fault insurance system, meaning that if you’re involved in a car accident, your Personal Injury Protection (PIP) insurance covers medical expenses and lost wages—but not pain and suffering. However, you may pursue a claim for pain and suffering if:

You suffered a significant and permanent loss of an important bodily function.
You sustained a permanent injury.
You have significant and permanent scarring or disfigurement.
The accident resulted in death.

If your injuries meet these thresholds, you can step outside the no-fault system and file a lawsuit against the at-fault party.

In short, to get compensated for pain and suffering, you must prove to an insurance company that you have experienced physical and mental distress.

Proving Pain and Suffering in Florida

Because pain and suffering are subjective, solid documentation is crucial to supporting your claim. Helpful evidence includes:

Medical records that detail the extent of your injuries.
Doctor’s statements confirming long-term impact, such as ongoing medical treatments, physical therapy, or surgeries required due to the injury.
Mental health evaluations documenting anxiety, PTSD, or depression, which can provide professional insight into the psychological toll of the accident.
Personal journals describing daily pain, emotional distress, and challenges in daily life. For example, detailing sleepless nights, difficulty performing daily tasks, or missing out on important life events due to your injuries.
Testimony from family and friends who have witnessed your struggles, including changes in your behavior, mood, and overall well-being since the accident.
Expert witness statements assessing how the injury affects your future, such as a medical professional explaining how chronic pain may impact your ability to work or enjoy life the way you used to.

How Much Should You Ask for Pain and Suffering?

The amount you can claim depends on the severity of your injuries and their long-term impact.

Severity of the injury – A minor whiplash injury will likely result in a lower settlement than a severe spinal cord injury or amputation.
Impact on daily activities and ability to work – If you can no longer perform your job or basic tasks, this will influence the compensation amount.
Duration of pain and suffering – Long-term or lifelong suffering warrants higher compensation than temporary discomfort.
Emotional and psychological effects – Anxiety, PTSD, and depression may further increase the settlement amount.
Likelihood of full recovery or permanent disability – Permanent impairments that alter quality of life can lead to higher compensation.

Much like anything in the law, the subjective aspects of experiences are calculated using a set formula.

How Is Pain and Suffering Calculated in Florida?

Unlike economic damages (such as medical bills or lost income), pain and suffering do not have an exact dollar value. Instead, attorneys, insurance companies, and courts typically use multipliers or per diem (daily rate) methods to determine compensation.

Multiplier Method:

Your total economic damages (medical bills, lost wages, etc.) are multiplied by a number between 1.5 and 5.
The multiplier depends on factors like severity of injuries, impact on daily life, and emotional distress.
Example: If your medical bills and lost wages total $50,000, and your case is assigned a 3x multiplier, your pain and suffering compensation would be $150,000.

Per Diem Method:

A daily dollar amount is assigned based on the level of suffering.
This amount is multiplied by the number of days you have experienced and are expected to experience pain.
Example: If the daily rate is $200 and you suffer for 365 days, your compensation would be $73,000.

How Insurance Companies Estimate Pain and Suffering

But since the full picture of pain and suffering is a unique circumstance that cannot be quantified in all subjective aspects mentioned above most insurance companies will use a formula that follows these three steps:

The amount you already owe. The insurer will add up all your expenses including medical costs, car repairs/replacement, therapies, and all other quantifiable costs related to the car accident.
The rating of your situation. This is usually the part of this equation that’s most difficult to prove because insurance companies then need to “rate” the severity of your condition, which can be very subjective. They usually assign numbers 1-5 depending on the long-term emotional consequences of your injuries or the experience.
The starting cause is multiplied by the rating. For instance, if your total expenses for the car accident amounted to $100,000 and you were rated 4 because you are left unable to walk for a year, then your total claim for pain and suffering will be $400,00 following the formula of ($100,000 x 4 = $400,000).

Although this is not a set method yet, most insurance companies follow this equation because it’s the most logical way to calculate pain and suffering.

The full impact of your injuries goes beyond just medical expenses—it affects your entire way of life. This is why securing the right compensation is crucial. Next, we’ll discuss why working with a personal injury lawyer is often the best step toward ensuring you get the full amount you deserve.

Pain and Suffering: An Example

John Smith is driving down Interstate 275 in his sedan, heading to work at Busch Gardens on a bright Saturday morning. Traffic stops in front of him on the highway, so John stops as well. However, the large pickup truck behind John doesn’t see traffic stop and slams into the back of John’s car.

The impact sends John through the guard railing and into the ditch on the side of the road. When paramedics arrive, he is unconscious and has several broken bones in his arm, as well as broken ribs that punctured his lungs. He’s rushed to the emergency room, where he is diagnosed with a severe traumatic brain injury, as well as other major injuries.

John ends up missing several weeks of work, during which his role is filled, leaving him out of a job. He also endures several weeks of painful rehabilitation, and his doctors say he will never fully recover from the traumatic brain injury. He also suffers from post-traumatic stress disorder and loses all enjoyment in life.

Between medical bills, lost wages, lost earning capacity, and other economic losses, John’s Tampa car accident lawyer calculates his economic damages at $500,000. His lawyer also claims that the multiplier should be set at five, since the accident completely disrupted his life, will have long-term effects, and he will never fully recover.

During negotiations, the insurance company pushes back and says the multiplier should be set at four. John’s lawyer and the insurance company compromise at 4.5. In total, John’s attorney wins $2.25 million.

Of course, this is a theoretical scenario that may or may not match any car accident that has ever happened or will ever happen. If you have been in a car accident, an experienced lawyer can help you determine how much you may be owed in economic and noneconomic damages.

Should You Hire a Lawyer for a Pain and Suffering Claim?

Insurance companies often downplay or dispute pain and suffering claims, making it difficult to secure fair compensation on your own. Our car accident lawyer can gather strong evidence to prove the extent of your pain and suffering, negotiate a higher settlement with the insurance company, and, if necessary, take your case to trial to fight for the compensation you deserve.

At Steinger, Greene & Feiner, we have helped accident victims recover over $1 BILLION in settlements and verdicts. If you’ve suffered serious injuries in Florida, we’re here to help. Contact us today for a free consultation!

Have questions? Call our accident attorneys at (800) 560-5059 anytime, we’re here to help

Get in Touch

Free Case Evaluation